2005 Jeep Liberty Total Loss March 29, 2021 by Robert McDorman Posted March 29, 2021 2005 Jeep Liberty Total Loss USAA Insurance had deemed our client’s 2005 Jeep Liberty a Total Loss and offered him a settlement of $3,669.75. We successfully settled his claim for a settlement of $4,830.00. Net settlement increase was $1,160.25 or 31.6%.